About 2 years ago, I reviewed John O'Dowd's superb biography of tragic 1950s movie star Barbara Payton in the Bay Area Reporter.
This morning O'Dowd emailed me to tell me that my op-ed piece for Truth Wins Out (see my last post) was brilliant and courageous.
Rabbi Sydney Mintz of San Francisco's Temple Emanuel, an out lesbian, says she agrees with my message. The Rabbi & I will meet in her office to discuss it in early August.
At Truth Wins Out, a number of people posted comments that my message was right and important~~that it's time to stop letting bitchy queens/angry dykes ruin the community for the rest of us.
It's time for us to come together and be a real community.
The widely read site Ex Gay Watch linked my article.
No, I don't always think I'm right, but I knew I was right about this, and I'm proud of the stand I'm taking.
The most fascinating reaction I got came from a person named David Roache.
Roache is someone I was aquainted with for all of two months earlier this year.
I don't think he & I ever enjoyed each other's company, though I certainly had nothing against him.
I barely know him.
We stopped talking about two months ago~~he was preparing to move to New York to study music, as far as I know he has since done so.
I forgot about him, but he didn't forget me. He began sending nasty taunts to this blog, taunts that were directed at me and at others who posted comments here. I rejected them.
I'm happy to post comments from those who disagree with me, but I refuse to post name calling, as Roache was doing.
A few days ago, I got a particularly nasty piece of abuse from David Roache. I rejected it, then emailed him and asked him to stop.
Below, you can see his response. The email from me appears beneath that:
From: David RoacheSent: Monday, July 6, 2009 7:35 PMTo: david1956@
Subject: RE: your comment has been rejected
Looks like I was right, you will always censor out things that don't agree with your "wisdom." Lol...not that I am surprised. Grow up and learn to respect other points of view. I am sure you are talking shit and whining to people right now about what I wrote. Oooohhhh, I care so much if you talk about me the way you say things about that Alice and Chris who claimed abused you and made you cry. Wasting time reading your blog? You're the one who bugged me all the time about reading it, and now you call reading it a waste of my time? Get real, dumbass. No wonder you have so many problems in your relationships and why so many people "abuse" you, as you claim. LOL.
From: david1956@
To: northridgeartist@
Subject: your comment has been rejected
Date: Mon, 6 Jul 2009 10:03:29 +0000
I have rejected your comment, and I've deleted your attacks against my good friend Michael Airhart.
No further comments from you will be posted.
I had actually forgotten about you.
Since you want nothing to do with me, I can't imagine why you're wasting your time reading my blog.
Aren't you on the East Coast now?
Why are you still thinking of me?
You need to move on.
David N
Keep in mind that the above was sent to me by someone I barely know~~I feel justified in posting it because he demanded that I stop "censoring" him and post his comments.
In the past 3-4 years, several people have claimed that I'm harrassing and stalking them.
Every single one of them behaved as David Roache did, but each refuses to be honest about their own actions.
I'd never said an unkind word to or about David Roache. He no longer lives in the Bay Area, and he wasn't hearing from me.
He sought me out. He came after me specifically to say things he thought would hurt me. He wanted to hurt me as deeply as he could because he thinks that hurting people is fun.
All he did was prove my point.
The tone and language of his taunt is all too familiar to me. It's behavior I've seen continuously in the LGBT community.
Gay men think this kind of nastiness is "campy". Lesbians find it "empowering."
While not all of us act this way, it's safe to say that this behavior has been out of control in the LGBT community for decades.
Roache's abuse is also indicitave of how I myself behaved for nearly twenty years. It was all I knew, it's how I was taught to behave by my gay elders in the 1970s. It's behavior I'm now deeply, profoundly ashamed of.
I continue to wage a battle against my old patterns. Most of the time I do OK, but sometimes I slip up.
Michael Airhart of Truth Wins Out has become instrumental in helping me to recognize and stop the slip-ups when they happen.
But many, many others in our community, enjoy the nastiness and want it to continue~~David Roache is a perfect example of this.
The last time I spoke to him, he was plotting "revenge" against a music teacher he didn't like.
This kind of behavior is the reason we were
unable to come together and defeat Prop 8.
It's causing other communities to turn against us.
It's bleeding our souls dry.
Is that really what want?
It may be what Mr. Roache wants, but judging from the reactions others are giving me, a LOT of people are tired of the status quo.
People are hungry for a real, nurturing and supportive community.
David Roache and others like him may find
themselves on the wrong side of history.
Nothing has validated my message more than this story that appeared in last week's San Francisco Bay Times:
http://www.sfbaytimes.com/?sec=article&article_id=10995In his article: You're So Vain You Probably Think This Forum's About You, Tom Orr addresses an ongoing problem: LGBT exclusion of each other, and what we can do to change it.
Mr. Orr shows that I'm not the only one addressing this topic~~it's an idea whose time has come.
David Alex Nahmod
SF CA
July 2009